Tickets| Jim Ard. | 1970-H.M. AP, UPI |
| Lloyd Batts | 1973-3rd team Basketball Weekly; 1974-H.M. AP, Sporting News. |
| Ron Bonham | 1963-1st team consensus (AP, UPI, Basketball Writers, Helms Foundation, Converse, Coaches Assoc.); 3rd team NEA; Player of the Year-Columbus TD Club. 1964-2nd team AP, UPI, Converse, 3rd team Coaches Assoc. |
| Bobby Brannen | 1998-H.M. Basketball Weekly. |
| Steve Collier | 1976-H.M. Street & Smith. |
| Pat Cummings | 1979-Citizens Savings |
| Dick Dallmer | 1948-H.M. AP; 1949 -H.M. AP; 1950-3rd team AP. |
| Ralph Davis | 1960-2nd team Converse. |
| Connie Dierking. | 1958-2nd team NEA. |
| Danny Fortson | 1995-Freshman Basketall Weekly; 1996-1st team Basketball Weekly, College Sports; 2nd team AP, Basketball America, Basketball Times, UPI, U.S. Basketball Writers, John Wooden; 1997-1st team consensus (Associated Press, Bas |
| Paul Hogue | 1961-2nd team Converse; 1962-1st team Basketball Writers, Helms Foundation, 2nd team NEA, Coaches Assoc.; 3rd team AP, UPI; Player of the Year-Helms Foundation. |
| DerMarr Johnson | 2000-Freshman All-American, The Sporting News |
| Herb Jones | 1992-H.M. AP |
| Melvin Levett | 1999-H.M. AP |
| Steve Logan | 2001-H.M. AP; 2002-1st team consensus (AP, USA Today/ESPN, Basketball News, Basketball Times, NABC, Naismith, Sporting News, U.S. Basketball Writers Assoc., John Wooden) |
| Kenyon Martin | 1999-H.M. AP; 2000 -1st team consensus (AP, USA Today/ESPN, Basketball News, Basketball Times, NABC, The Sporting News, U.S. Basketball Writers Assoc., John Wooden); Player of the Year (AP, U.S. Basketball Writers Assoc., |
| Pete Mickeal | 3rd team, AP |
| Robert Miller | 1978-H.M. AP |
| Ruben Patterson | 1998-H.M. AP |
| Oscar Robertson | 1958-1st team consensus (AP, UPI, Basketball Writers, Sporting News, NEA, Helms Foundation; Player of the Year-UPI, Sporting News; 1959-1st team consensus; Player of the Year-AP, UPI, Sporting News, Basketball Writers, He |
| Mike Rolf | 1967-Academic All-American, CoSIDA. |
| Tom Thacker | 1963-1st team UPI, Basketball Writers, Sporting News, NEA, Helms Foundation; 2nd team AP. |
| Jack Twyman | 1955-2nd team NEA, Intl. News Service, Tempo; H.M. Converse. |
| Nick Van Exel | 1993-3rd team AP, Basketball Times, Basketball Weekly, H.M. Scripps Howard. |
| Bob Wiesenhahn | 1961-1st team Helms Foundation, Converse. |
| George Wilson | 1963-2nd team Sporting News, Converse. |
| Dontonio Wingfield | 1994-Freshman Basketball Weekly. |
| Tony Yates | 1962-2nd team Helms Foundation; H.M. UPI; 1963-1st team Helms Foundation; 3rd team AP, NABC; H.M. The Sporting News, UPI. |
| Gary Yoder | 1977-H.M. Citizens Savings Foundation. |